Evidence base for Homeopathy
From
time to time, studies are done to measure the effectiveness of homeopathic
treatment.
However,
many of these studies try to fit homeopathy into the same research model that is
used to test conventional medicine ie Randomised Controlled Trials (RCTs).
Given
that homeopathy is a ‘bespoke’ service, with remedies being tailored to the
individual, it is impossible to give a control group the same remedy for a
particular condition and expect meaningful results. In fact some of these
particular trials show that homeopathy fares even worse than placebo.
Increasingly,
qualitative studies using the MYMOP system (measure your medical outcome) www.hsrc.ac.uk/mymop/main.htm
are being used. This is a
validated research tool and involves patients filling in a detailed
questionnaire about presenting symptoms and wellbeing, and giving them a score
at each appointment.
Two recent
studies show homeopathy to be very effective.
The
first is a 6 year study by the Bristol Homeopathic Hospital involving several
thousand patients, where 70% of patients showed improvement.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/bristol/4454856.stm
The
second study took place in a Nottinghamshire primary care trust, and involved
patients referred by their GPs for acupuncture, chiropractic and homeopathy.70%
showed symptom amelioration, and patients gave glowing accounts of their
treatment. For more information go to: www.impact-imp.co.uk
See
also The Society of Homeopaths www.homeopathy-soh.com
for an update on research in progress.